The recently published book,Truth Before Reconciliation: Confronting Residential School Denialism, edited by academics/polemicists Sean Carleton and Niigaan Sinclair, is academically atrocious, grossly insults all past and present non-Aboriginal Canadians, and grossly insult the sacrifices and memories of the six million Jewish Holocaust victims.
Like malign Don Quixotes, they and the contributors to this unscholarly collection of essays and interviews (sometimes referred to collectively as “Carleton and Sinclair”) imagine the non-existent twin windmills of Indian residential school genocide and culpable “denial” of it by present day Canadians. Then, throughout the book, they purport to prove the former and “confront” the latter, the only result of which, for the reader, is that, like Don Quixote did, they reveal themselves as fools.
But Don Quixote was positive, funny and elevating in its universalist humanity.
Truth Before Reconciliation is dark and disloyal in its embodiment of the mean-spiritedness and wrongheadedness that characterize the constant attacks against Canada and Canadians being made by the Aboriginal establishment.
In addition, this book’s publication reveals once again the debased academic and ethical standards now governing faculties of “Indigenous Studies”.
The starting point of Truth Before Reconciliation is that it asserts it to be an incontrovertible fact – like the law of gravity – that Canada committed genocide against its Aboriginal peoples by way of residential schools, the same, the book claims, as the Holocaust genocide committed against the Jews of Europe.
Any comparison of the situation of the Jewish people and the Holocaust with that of Aboriginal people in Canada is demeaning and degrading to the memory and sacrifices of six million true Holocaust victims.
Such a totally false comparison in effect forgets and denies their unfathomable sufferings and deaths and the unfathomable evil that brought those sufferings and deaths about.
The book also claims that this purported genocide by education, like the existence of gravity, should not be open to debate or dispute:
“That residential schools were a genocide is a settled issue that is not controversial because a consensus opinion has been formed.”
To Carleton and Sinclair, so plain and obvious is the truth of this purportedly unquestionable fact – this “settled issue”- that any Canadian who disputes it is to them akin to a Holocaust denier who deserves censure and punishment.
The only “proof” that Carleton and Sinclair offer for their settled-issue/“consensus opinion” genocide is a mere collection of recent political and politically inspired happenings and opinions: the Truth and Reconciliation Commission Final Report, (the result of unsworn, untested, self-interested testimony of witnesses at TRC hearings), the 2006 Indian Residential School Settlement Agreement, the Harper government’s 2008 apology in Parliament, the passage by Parliament of the genocide resolution in 2022, a contested Canadian Historical Association resolution to this effect, and various, unnamed “peer review studies” referred to by them.
None of this is academically authoritative, historical proof. Rather, it’s the mere equivalent of present-day, hearsay, political gossip. It’s shocking that any academic would offer this frivolous tripe as evidence of genocide.
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and there is no evidence at all in Truth Before Reconciliation.
Canadians who would dare to disagree with Carleton and Sinclair, including this writer, are described to be racism-promoting “residential school deniers”, who “draw on the Holocaust denialism playbook”, who reject “reconciliation”, whose motivations are to “defend the colonial status quo”, and who “selectively remember the past to protect their own power and privilege in the present” and make money from their “denialist discourse” which, according to them, “degrades Indigenous people”.
(As to our motivation to “defend the colonial status quo”, that’s partially correct. But more exactly, it’s truth and the honour of Canada and of past and present Canadians we seek to defend.)
Carleton and Sinclair even go so far as to absurdly say that “denialists” are trying to “redeem the British Empire, protect its spoils and weaponize imperial heritage as a political tool”. (Trotsky at his most paranoid and delusional couldn’t have said it better.)
Therefore, according to Carleton and Sinclair, such “deniers” should never be engaged or debated with, because, the genocide being said to be a “settled issue/consensus opinion”, to do so would only enable them to “attack truth and reconciliation” and would “platform and legitimize… colonizers”, who in “bad faith” use “discursive strategies…tools and discourse to defend their material power, privilege and profit”.
In other words, “deniers” make counterarguments against this purportedly unquestionable genocide fact, which, to Carleton and Sinclair, are “hurtful” and inherently wrong – even criminally wrong- to make.
Evidenced by their close-minded certainty, Carleton and Sinclair reject or, more likely, are unaware of the operating assumption of all serious historians to the effect that a complete picture of past or present reality – historical, human and otherwise – is simply not to be had – and that all historical facts come to us from interpretive choices of historians influenced by the standards of their age.
They reject or are unaware of Arnold Toynbee’s expression of this reality[i]:
“In any age of any society the study of history, like other social activities, is governed by the dominant tendencies of the time and the place…. History is protean. You have no sooner caught history in one shape than it changes shape like Proteus- sometimes out of all recognition. The whole of the past looks different in the light of our additional experiences of life…. Men see largely what they expect to see, and they record what to them seems important.”
Toynbee’s widely accepted historicist view presumes that for historical inquiry to be worthwhile, hard work, a disciplined knowledge of and adherence to facts, and a sense of humility and doubt must be present on the part of the inquiring historian; all qualities absent from Truth Before Reconciliation.
Raymond Aron[ii], criticizing fanatical Marxists, wrote that “any theory which exempts itself from all refutations escapes from the order of truth”.
Truth Before Reconciliation demands this exemption, and in so doing, exhibits the same grim, intellectual childishness as the Marxism fanatics Aron was writing about.
Carleton and Sinclair deny that those who make counterarguments can be well-intentioned, thus insulting the majority of their countrymen.
They also dismiss all objective facts and good faith arguments advanced to justify or contextualize residential schools as “moves to innocence”, “cherry-picking” and as attempts to present “false balance”.
As to contextualizing, they disagree with the late Professor Robert Carney, who wrote about and lived Aboriginal residential school and day school education all his adult life. In his defence of the need for and efficacy of residential schools he wrote that “relevant comparisons and context are necessary tools of the historian’s trade”.
Again, unlike all serious historians, Carleton and Sinclair ignore the reality of the world historical phenomenon of migration of peoples, which from time immemorial has caused dispossession and assimilation, and which demands contextualization and comparisons in any historical work dealing with it. Historian Simon Sebag Montefiore[iii] calls this phenomenon “the engine of all world history and of the present”.
In Canada’s case the migration of British and French Europeans to this land is one of the most peaceful and honourable examples of this eternal phenomenon that the last 3000 years of world history has to offer; a contextualizing fact to celebrate, not ignorantly denigrate.
Carleton and Sinclair try to give the appearance of haute academe by using pretentious language. Instead of simply saying why residential school “denialism” is wrong on its merits they purport to “theorize” and “historicize” it. In so doing they grandiloquently call themselves “witnesses” to history. (How can one “witness” what is long past?)
They pedantically call free-speech arguments “techniques of neutralization” and “moves to innocence.” They talk about analysing “discursive strategies” of Canadians who disagree with them. They call their research “liberatory”. (As to the latter, this means being biased from the outset with the view of “liberating” Aboriginal people from “colonial” oppression. So café intellectual.)
As Clive James said:
“The wretched of the earth get no help from witch doctors, and when academic language gets beyond shouting distance of ordinary speech, voodoo is all it is.”
By refusing to engage with and thus “platform” valid counterarguments to their charge of genocide – in other words, to suppress them – Carleton and Sinclair eschew the Enlightenment traditions and values of the true intellectual and of the traditional university, and reveal their radical, insecure, provincial mindset.
Contributor Raymond Frogner is right up front on this. Speaking for them all, he proudly says:
“I reject the denialist claim for the neutrality of Enlightenment research models. All knowledge is socially mediated.”
(Except Truth Before Reconciliation’s “settled issue”/claimed fact that Canada committed genocide against its Aboriginal peoples, which, like the law of gravity, is of course, for Frogner et al, not “socially mediated”.)
Not for Carlton and Sinclair the open-minded, welcoming, curious and confident intellectualism of Ralph Waldo Emerson, who wrote in his famous essay, The Conduct of Life:
“The wise man throws himself on the side of his assailants. It is more his interest than it is theirs to find his weak points.”
Not for Carleton and Sinclair the precept of the French philosopher Montaigne, who wrote:
“When I am contradicted it arouses my attention, not my wrath. I move towards the man who contradicts me; he is instructing me. The cause of truth ought to be common to us all.”
Carleton and Sinclair proclaim that all “deniers” are bad-intentioned, unqualified, “far right” amateurs. They try to deflect and defuse their strong counterarguments mainly by discrediting their qualifications, which as Raymond Aron said, is “a reflex amongst established gurus to watch out for”.
Truth Before Reconciliation is touted as an effective instruction manual on how to “neutralize” these amateurs.
“Many residential school denialists self-publish books and articles and engage in pseudo-scholarship to give their unethical work the appearance of academic credibility and legitimacy. As such, we felt strongly that this book needed to be subject to the rigours of the formal peer-review process to maximize quality, accuracy and authority. Undergoing anonymous peer-review always means more work, but the reward is putting forth the best possible scholarship.”
The “best possible scholarship” on Sinclair’s and Carleton’s genocide claim would normally come from widely accepted, legitimately credentialed genocide scholars, like Timothy Snyder and Simon Sebag Montefiore.
But Truth Before Reconciliation demonstrates that neither Carleton nor Sinclair nor any of the other contributors to ithave the academic credibility and legitimacy to produce the “best possible scholarship” on this profound topic, and judging by the book, which assures the reader that it was anonymously “rigorously peer-reviewed”, neither did the obviously rigour-free, unidentified “peers”.
Carleton is an Associate Professor of History. His past academic writings focus on Aboriginal schooling and its allegedly material connection to “capitalism” in colonial B.C. and on graphic/comic book portrayals of history, none of which relates to a purported Canadian genocide of Aboriginal peoples.
Sinclair is a Professor of Indigenous Studies, not of History. His past academic writings are about “Indigenous literature”, “Indigenous literary nationalism”, “Indigenous poetics” and similar literary-related Aboriginal topics.
There are about 20 contributors to Truth Before Reconciliation, including Carleton and Sinclair, none of which have any academic background or credentials in anything relating to the purported Canadian “genocide” they baldly assert occurred. Only about 5 of the 20 even use the word “historian” in their CV’s.
Of these, Krista McCracken calls herself a “settler public historian”. Sky-Lee Storm Hogan-Stacy only has an M.A. in History and writes about “data sovereignty”. Adele Perry is a professor in “History and Women’s and Gender Studies”. Erin Millions is an Assistant Professor of History who writes about “residential schools and commemoration”. These contributors, neither in their past academic writings nor in Truth Before Reconciliation have written anything scholarly and authoritative about an alleged Canadiangenocide.
The rest of the academic contributors to the book are Indigenous Studies Department archivists, anthropologists and sociology types, all, from the comfort of their various faculty lounges in their colonialism-created universities, with an “anti-colonial” ax to grind, again, possessing no academic credentials to support writing or saying anything historically authoritative about an Aboriginal genocide having allegedly happened in Canada.
The last contributors – Phyllis Webstad, Michelle Good, Leah Gazan – mere interviewees in the book- are Aboriginal- related public personalities possessing no academic credentials whatsoever.
The “best possible scholarship” indeed!
Carleton and Sinclair, with the contempt they show for ordinary citizens who, for love of country, dare to publicly weigh in on profound Aboriginal issues of national interest and consequence, thusly performing a good citizen’s public duty, epitomize Academia’s worst priesthood-like tendencies, well-described by Egon Friedell:
And then there were the Scholars, the key holders of all life’s riddles, the academic devotees and initiates. A new aristocracy arose…far more impatient, inaccessible, caste-proud, inhuman and inaccessible than the old.”
In fact, the published criticisms of Truth Before Reconciliation and its genocide theme by “amateurs” in such books as Grave Error and Dead Wrong are far more intellectually credible and legitimate than anything written by Carleton and Sinclair and their caste of contributors.
Some of the contributors to these “denialist” books can indeed be characterized as “amateurs”, but that’s to their credit.
Egon Friedell praised dilletantes -amateurs- those who write not for profit or career, but rather for passion – as follows:
“As regards dilettantism, it should be borne in mind that vital energy dwells in any activities only so long as they are practised by amateurs. It is the amateur, happily so named, who alone stands in a really human relation to his objects; only in amateurs do the man and his professions coincide. That is why an amateur can pour his own self into his activity, saturating it with the essence of his being; whereas things which are practised as a profession have invariably a touch of the worse sort of lovingness, whether it takes the form of a particular one-sidedness or limitation, of subjectivity or narrowness of outlook. The expert is too tightly wedged into his professional circle and is almost never in a position to bring about a real revolution. He has grown up with tradition and respects it in spite of himself. Also, he knows too much detail of his subject to see things simply enough, and, losing that, he loses the first essential of intellectual fertility. Thus the whole history of the sciences affords a continuous example of the value of dilettantism…Particularly when we come to cultural history will it be found positively impossible to handle the subject except in the amateur spirit.”
In this amateur spirit Michelle Stirling, in her review of the book shows its academic worthlessness.
In this amateur spirit Michael Melanson cogently reviewed the book, highlighting its fundamentally gaslighting nature.
In this amateur spirit Nina Green demolishes the argument that residential schools were “genocidal”.
In this amateur spirit Aboriginal Elaine Ayoungman Clifton offers her personal remembrances of her positive residential school experience.
These citizens’ heroic, Olympic-level work ethic and realism-based research and writing abilities put Carlton’s and Sinclair’s to shame.
Clive James wrote that in his time:
“The universities were hardening further into hieratic structures where nothing mattered except the prestige of position- a characteristic that made them fatally corruptible by political pressure.”
It’s worse today, especially regarding Indigenous Studies faculties, which have abandoned all traditional scholarship values, standards and practices in favour of shallow, careerist, false-narrative, government-pleasing propaganda. They’ve become hacks and mouthpieces for the Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal establishments, as have the universities that employ them.
The contributors to Truth Before Reconciliation use their obvious ambition and cleverness to advance not just their careers, but more harmfully to Canada, to advance anti-intellectual, illiberal ends – the false, blood libelling and resulting disunity and demoralization of the country, and the saddling of Aboriginal Canadians with an unjustified and debilitating victimhood complex.
They argue history while showing that they know none. They show themselves to be mere ideologues, who, as such, are forced to conceal and avoid unpalatable truths.[iv]
Hence their fear of truly engaging with the cogent counterarguments of such citizens as Michelle Stirling, Michael Melanson and Nina Green, and of all their colleagues on the Indian Residential Research Group website (all contributors to Grave Error and Dead Wrong), who publish similarly cogent articles disproving any Canadian genocide, exposing Carleton and Sinclair for the academic lightweights they are, and defending Canada and past and present Canadians.
Instead of dealing honestly and on their merits with the facts and counterarguments of these caring Canadians Carleton and Sinclair merely dismiss and deflect away from them by saying they are “not experts” whose “independently published” work has not been “peer-reviewed”. For these academic snobs, it’s enough that they’re just not part of their imagined academic priesthood.
True professionals – true scholars- show respect for and deal fairly with one another, even if they disagree on professional issues. Contributor Frogner sets out a key part of the traditional ethical standards governing academe:
“Ad hominem attacks are typically not the kind of rhetorical avenues that we use in scholarly publications and academic work. That would be nonsense…Ignoring evidence and insulting people is not a robust form of scholarship.”
But this is exactly what Truth Before Reconciliation does – it ignores evidence and insults people.
One particularly audacious set of insults are Carleton’s and Sinclair’s baseless and unethical attacks against the personal and professional integrity of established, accomplished Professors who disagree with them – Professors who are clearly Carleton’s and Sinclair’s academic seniors and “betters”- which attacks epitomize their reckless, unethical degradation of academe and its finer traditions.
One of the editors of Grave Error is Professor Emeritus Tom Flanagan, a gentleman of personal, career and academic distinction and achievements.
Carleton and Sinclair accuse Professor Flanagan, as they shamefully do all the others named below, of acting in “bad faith”, and, with no reasons given, referring to Grave Error, of presiding over and participating in an “unethical work”- a work of “pseudo-history” containing many (unspecified)“falsehoods and conspiracy theories”. They dismiss this accomplished Canadian as a “known residential school denialist” and, in the spirit of Roy Cohn-McCarthyism and Stalinist-style, pre-purge innuendo, as a “far right strategist”.
They dismiss and disrespect in the same unscholarly and unethical way other senior, full Professor-contributors to Grave Error– Bishops to country priests Carleton and Sinclair in their imagined academic priesthood- Professors Jacques Rouillard, Hymie Rubenstein, Ian Gentles and Rodney Clifton.
Thusly Truth Before Reconciliation represents the destabilizing rejection of established expertise and the disrespecting of distinguished non-Aboriginal elders, academic and otherwise, by populist-style know-littles, a dangerous and destabilizing phenomenon which permeates society today.
Lastly, anotherfull Professor – non-Aboriginal elder shamefully side-stepped and disparaged by Carleton and Sinclair is the late Professor J.R. Miller, of the University of Saskatchewan, who wrote Shingwauk’s Vision -A History of Residential Schools.
The following excerpt from Shingwauk’s Vision shows the truth that Aboriginal Chiefs wanted schools, wanted the education they knew their people needed in the new industrial/agrarian world they found themselves in, demanded school provisions in treaties, and participated in their formation and operation:
“But in the summer of 1876 at the Hudson Bay post where chiefs such as Ahtahkakoop and Mistawasis made treaty with Queen Victoria’s commissioner, the Native communities of the Saskatchewan country were motivated by a clear strategy. They sought access to learning that, they believed, would enable them to make a living in new ways and cope with the unanticipated intruders. No less than the Ojibwa chief Shingwaukonce who in the 1830’s paddled the long way to the provincial capital of York to ask the monarch’s representative for a missionary and a teacher for the children of his community, the Cree leaders at Fort Carleton who persuaded reluctant chiefs such as Poundmaker and Young Chipewyan to take treaty were seeking Euro-Canadian education to adapt, to cope with change …Native people participated in the creation of schools, whatever they might have thought of the way the institutions evolved…(They) were partners of a sort in the residential school experiment…with a desire to respond to Euro-Canadian incursions by adaptation rather than resistance or withdrawal…At Orillia in 1846 this thinking led Mississauga, Mohawk and other leaders to agree to the government’s proposal to establish manual labour schools , but also to pledge to support them with a portion of their annuities.” (italics added)
Professor Miller, along with many other luminaries of Canadian historical scholarship, expressly rejected what he called the “genocide myth” perpetrated by Truth Before Reconciliation.
The only recorded genocide in Canadian history is the genocide of the Hurons by the Iroquois in the late 1640’s.That’s why there are no Hurons living near Lake Huron today.
There was never a Canadian genocide of Aboriginals by non-Aboriginals.
The assertion is sick and preposterous.
This is the truth that must be understood and accepted before there can be reconciliation – the truth that is being “denied”, buried, avoided and distorted by our post-Enlightenment liberal arts universities, by propagandist academics like Carleton and Sinclair who are employed and promoted by them, and by academically shoddy, unethical and irresponsible books like Truth Before Reconciliation.
Peter Best
Sudbury
October 31, 2026
[i] Arnold Toynbee- A Study of History, The First Abridged One Volume Addition- Weathervane Books, New York, 1972
[ii] Quotations from Raymond Aron and Egon Friedell are from the late humanist Clive James’ 2007 Cultural Amnesia – Necessary Memories from History and the Arts.
[iii] In The Cauldron -The Making of the Modern Middle East, Alfred A. Knopf, New York, 2026
The full quote: “Foreign invaders, colonists, migrants and settlers – such movements of people are the engine of all world history and of our present.”
[iv] The statements in these two paragraphs, adapted to apply to Carleton and Sinclair and contributors, are cribbed from Clive Barnes, above. As Egon Friedell wrote tongue in cheek: “Everyone in full possession of his faculties is continuously being compelled to plagiarize. The well-ordered, well-refined realm of truth is small; only the wilderness of folly and error, caprice and idiocy, is boundless and bottomless.”